HypaVault vs Private Photo VaultWhich Vault Can You Trust with Your Photos?
HypaVault is ad-free and encrypts every file with AES-256-GCM, while Private Photo Vault’s free version shows ads and tests of older versions found photos stored readable.
Meets these 10 privacy basics
The Short Answer
Private Photo Vault is hugely popular and now says it encrypts files with AES, but its free version is ad-supported, and independent tests of older versions, from 2014 to 2019, found stored photos readable and the passcode in plaintext. Its decoy password opens a second vault without erasing anything, and its only backup is the paid Cloud Vault service. HypaVault encrypts every file, name and thumbnail on the phone with AES-256-GCM, carries no advertising, works without an account and backs each vault up as an encrypted file you keep. Its duress passcode erases your real vaults in one silent step, which makes it the stronger choice for photos that must stay private.
- HypaVault is ad-free and encrypts every file with AES-256-GCM, while Private Photo Vault’s free version shows ads and tests of older versions found photos stored readable.
- Private Photo Vault’s decoy password opens a second vault but erases nothing, while HypaVault’s duress passcode opens an empty vault and erases the rest.
- HypaVault backs each vault up as an encrypted file you keep and costs $39.99 once, while Private Photo Vault’s backup is its paid Cloud Vault.
Feature by Feature
The 10 things that decide whether a vault really keeps your files private.
| Feature | HypaVault | Private Photo Vault |
|---|---|---|
| Files encrypted on the phone | YesAES-256-GCM, with a key for every file | PartlyClaims AES; tests of old versions found flaws (2014 to 2019) |
| Works without an account or email | YesA passcode and a recovery phrase, nothing more | PartlyAccount needed only for paid Cloud Vault |
| Files stay on your phone | YesEncrypted on the phone; it leaves only when you send it | PartlyOffline by default; optional paid Cloud Vault |
| Ad-free | YesPaid for by Pro, never by advertising | NoFree Basic version shows ads; Ad-Free is Premium |
| Duress passcode that erases data | YesOpens an empty vault and erases the rest | NoNone listed; its decoy erases nothing |
| Decoy or empty vault | YesThe duress passcode opens an empty vault | YesDecoy Password opens a separate decoy vault |
| Calculator or clock disguise | YesWorking calculator or alarm clock, with matching icon | PartlyDiscreet alternate icons; no calculator found |
| Separate hidden vaults | YesUp to three, none aware of the others | PartlyOne decoy vault, plus Premium album locks |
| Encrypted backup you keep | YesOne encrypted .hypa file per vault, checked before it's saved, kept where you choose | PartlyPaid Cloud Vault on the developer’s service |
| Pay-once option | Yes$39.99 once, or $24.99 a year | Not stated$39.99 “Upgrade” listed; one-time unconfirmed |
What You'll Pay
Private Photo Vault's prices as listed in the US stores, checked 27 October 2026.
HypaVault
- Free
- A full encrypted vault, with limits
- Yearly
- $24.99 a year, after a 3-day free trial
- Pay once
- $39.99, with no renewals
Private Photo Vault
- Free
- Basic version with ads; limits not published
- Premium
- $6.99, $12.99, $35.99 or $39.99; Apple doesn’t list billing periods
- Upgrade
- $39.99; not confirmed as a one-time purchase
- Free trial
- Offered on the $6.99 subscription; length not stated
Where They Really Differ
Encryption, in Reality
Private Photo Vault
Legendary Software Labs says files in the app use AES encryption, with an extra AES-256 layer added on the phone before Cloud Vault uploads, and notes that its security page is product documentation, not an independent audit. Independent tests of older versions found serious weaknesses: Jonathan Zdziarski (2014) recovered stored photos and videos in cleartext, IOActive (2015) found photos unencrypted and passcodes in plaintext, and a Purdue study published in 2022, from tests run in 2019, found the PIN in plaintext. Those versions are years old, and we found no independent test of the current app.
HypaVault
Every file, name, folder, note and thumbnail is encrypted on the phone with AES-256-GCM before it's saved, each file with its own random 256-bit key. A copy of the files is unreadable without your passcode and the phone's own device key.
Account Dependency
Private Photo Vault
The on-device vault works without an account, and the developer says the app is offline by default. Cloud Vault, the paid backup and sync, needs an account and an internet connection, and the developer says the cloud backup is deleted when you switch back to the free Basic version.
HypaVault
Setup is a 6-digit passcode and a 12-word recovery phrase. You never give HypaVault an email or a phone number, so there's no login to phish and your vault never depends on a company sign-in.
Ads and Data
Private Photo Vault
The free Basic version is ad-supported: Google Play lists “Contains ads” and sells Ad-Free as a Premium feature. Its self-reported App Store label lists advertising data as used to track you, and photos or videos, user and device IDs and purchase history as data linked to you. Google Play’s data safety section says device IDs are shared for analytics and advertising.
HypaVault
HypaVault is paid for by people who choose Pro, never by advertising. Its only outside service is RevenueCat, which records purchases and never sees your vaults.
Protection Under Pressure
Private Photo Vault
A Decoy Password, called Fake PIN on Google Play where it’s a Premium feature, opens a separate decoy vault, and break-in reports photograph intruders and record their location. The developer’s own security page warns that the decoy “is not a guarantee that another vault’s existence cannot be discovered.” We found no passcode that erases data in its store listings, features page or security page.
HypaVault
A second passcode for when you're forced to unlock. It looks like a normal unlock and opens an empty vault, while every other vault on the phone is erased in one silent step. Your backups bring them back later.
What People Say About Private Photo Vault
Recurring themes in public App Store and Google Play reviews and discussions, checked 27 October 2026. Follow the links to read them.
Pay-Once Buyers Moved to a Subscription
Long-time users who paid once for Pro or a lifetime unlock report that a 2026 update asks them to pay for Premium, says their subscription has expired, or shows ads again.
Intrusive Ads in the Free Version
Free users report long, frequent or hard-to-close ads, and some describe close buttons that don’t close the ad.
Photos Reported Lost After Updates
Reviewers report vault contents disappearing after an app update, a paywall change or a move to a new phone, in one case for the second time.
Crashes and Premium Error Loops
After recent updates, some reviewers say the app crashes on launch, or gets stuck in a loop saying it can’t load Premium features.
Slow Support and Cloud Vault Sign-in Errors
Reviewers with sync, password or billing problems say support stops replying, and some paying users report sign-in errors with Cloud Vault.
Why HypaVault Is the Better Choice
- Files encrypted on the phoneAES-256-GCM, with a key for every file.
- Works without an account or emailA passcode and a recovery phrase, nothing more.
- Files stay on your phoneEncrypted on the phone; it leaves only when you send it.
- Ad-freePaid for by Pro, never by advertising. Private Photo Vault doesn't offer this.
- Duress passcode that erases dataOpens an empty vault and erases the rest. Private Photo Vault doesn't offer this.
- Calculator or clock disguiseWorking calculator or alarm clock, with matching icon.
- Separate hidden vaultsUp to three, none aware of the others.
- Encrypted backup you keepOne encrypted .hypa file per vault, checked before it's saved, kept where you choose.
- Pay-once option$39.99 once, or $24.99 a year.
HypaVault vs Private Photo Vault: Questions
What people ask when choosing between HypaVault and Private Photo Vault.
For privacy, yes. Private Photo Vault’s free version is ad-supported, independent tests of older versions found photos readable, and its decoy password opens a second vault without erasing anything. HypaVault encrypts every file, name and thumbnail with AES-256-GCM, carries no advertising, works without an account and has a duress passcode that erases your real vaults.
The developer says files in the app use AES encryption, with AES-256 for Cloud Vault uploads, and calls its security page product documentation, not an independent audit. Independent tests of older versions, by Jonathan Zdziarski in 2014, IOActive in 2015 and Purdue researchers in a 2022 study of 2019 tests, found photos readable or the passcode stored in plaintext; we found no independent test of the current app. HypaVault encrypts every file on the phone with AES-256-GCM, each with its own random 256-bit key.
Read the Help ArticleNot for the vault on your phone, which the developer says is offline by default. Its paid Cloud Vault backup needs an account and an internet connection. HypaVault never asks for an account or email: setup is a 6-digit passcode and a 12-word recovery phrase, and backups are encrypted files you keep.
Read the Help ArticleYes, in the free Basic version. Google Play lists “Contains ads” and sells Ad-Free as a Premium feature, and its App Store privacy label lists advertising data as used to track you. HypaVault carries no advertising, and nothing in it reports what you do.
Read the Help ArticleNo. It has a Decoy Password that opens a separate decoy vault, which its own security page says is no guarantee that another vault can’t be discovered, but nothing in its listings or security page describes a passcode that erases data. HypaVault’s duress passcode looks like a normal unlock, opens an empty vault and erases every other vault in one silent step. Your backups bring them back later.
Read the Help ArticlePrivate Photo Vault is free with ads. Apple lists Premium at $6.99, $12.99, $35.99 and $39.99 without billing periods, plus a $39.99 “Private Photo Vault Upgrade” we couldn’t confirm as one-time; the developer says its old Pro version was a one-time purchase and it now sells a subscription. HypaVault is $24.99 a year after a 3-day free trial, or $39.99 once, and it carries no advertising.
Read the Help ArticleYes. Save the photos and videos from Private Photo Vault to your photo library or Files, then import them into HypaVault, which encrypts the photos, videos and documents you choose. If you use Cloud Vault, move your files before switching back to Basic, since the developer says the cloud backup is deleted then. Once they’re safely in HypaVault, delete the originals if you want them kept only there.
Read the Help ArticleWe couldn’t find a documented way to recover a forgotten passcode in the listings and developer pages we checked, and a 2026 Google Play reviewer reports finding no way to recover a password. HypaVault gives you a 12-word recovery phrase that resets a forgotten passcode. It’s shown once and never stored, so nobody, including Cyberdunes, can recover it for you; keep it written down somewhere safe.
Read the Help Article
More Comparisons
HypaVault vs Keepsafe
Keepsafe says it “can technically view or share your personal data in limited cases,” while HypaVault encrypts every file on your phone with AES-256-GCM in a vault that opens only with your passcode.
See the ComparisonHypaVault vs Hide It Pro
HypaVault encrypts every file with AES-256-GCM and carries no advertising, while Hide It Pro names no encryption method and shows ads on Android.
See the ComparisonHypaVault vs Privault
HypaVault documents its AES-256-GCM encryption and carries no advertising, while Privault calls its storage “encrypted” without naming a method and shows ads in its free version.
See the ComparisonHypaVault vs SPV
HypaVault encrypts every file with AES-256-GCM, while SPV’s listing promises PIN protection but makes no claim to encrypt your files.
See the ComparisonHypaVault vs Secret Photo Album
HypaVault encrypts every file on your phone with AES-256-GCM, while Secret Photo Album promises “encrypted” storage without saying how.
See the ComparisonHypaVault vs PV Secret Photo Album
PV Secret Photo Album is ad-supported and names only “AES,” while HypaVault is ad-free and encrypts every file with AES-256-GCM.
See the ComparisonSwitch from Private Photo Vault to HypaVault
Start free on iPhone, iPad or Android. Choose a passcode, write down your recovery phrase, and move your private files into a vault that's encrypted on your phone.
HypaVault is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by Legendary Software Labs LLC. Private Photo Vault - Pic Safe and its app icon are trademarks of their owner, shown only to identify the app. Details about Private Photo Vault come from its store listings, website and public reviews, checked 27 October 2026. Prices and features can change; check the store listing for the latest.
Sources
- https://apps.apple.com/us/app/private-photo-vault-pic-safe/id417571834
- https://apps.apple.com/us/app/private-photo-vault-pic-safe/id417571834?see-all=reviews
- https://itunes.apple.com/lookup?id=417571834&country=us
- https://itunes.apple.com/us/rss/customerreviews/page=2/id=417571834/sortby=mostrecent/json
- https://itunes.apple.com/us/rss/customerreviews/page=3/id=417571834/sortby=mostrecent/json
- https://itunes.apple.com/us/rss/customerreviews/page=6/id=417571834/sortby=mostrecent/json
- https://itunes.apple.com/us/rss/customerreviews/page=7/id=417571834/sortby=mostrecent/json
- https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.enchantedcloud.photovault&hl=en_US&gl=US
- https://play.google.com/store/apps/datasafety?id=com.enchantedcloud.photovault&hl=en_US&gl=US
- https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.enchantedcloud.photovault&hl=en_US&gl=US&reviewId=3885ecd6-6732-4126-aedc-7d8bc4bf3bf4
- https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.enchantedcloud.photovault&hl=en_US&gl=US&reviewId=d67216a1-e10a-46b4-a7eb-d3bff54eeeaa
- https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.enchantedcloud.photovault&hl=en_US&gl=US&reviewId=75d2caf9-5c01-435a-a71c-efd06ffa506f
- https://privatephotovault.com/
- https://privatephotovault.com/security/
- https://privatephotovault.com/faq/
- https://privatephotovault.com/features/
- https://privatephotovault.com/cloud-vault-encrypted-backups/
- https://zdziarski.com/blog/?p=3951
- https://www.ioactive.com/breaking-into-and-reverse-engineering-ios-photo-vaults/
- https://commons.erau.edu/jdfsl/vol17/iss1/1
- https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/035f/89fff8558c9a1ec630e19b69f642efa939e3.pdf
